Note: Durham police have now (8 July) accepted Keir Starmer and Angela Rayner have no case to answer on “beergate” – as suggested below
It’s an enigma wrapped in a mystery: how could the London Metropolitan Police possibly have decided the UK Prime Minister Boris Johnson attended a party on 13 November 2020 that was illegal under Covid regulations yet do so wholly lawfully? The regulations, after all, are clear:
8.—(1) No person may participate in a gathering which—
(a) consists of two or more people, and
(b) takes place indoors (including indoors within a private dwelling).
(The Health Protection (Coronavirus, Restrictions) (England) (No. 4) Regulations 2020)
There were exceptions in Reg. 11 for gatherings “reasonably necessary” for “work purposes” – but no exemption for work parties nor for a prime minister who clearly “participated” in the gathering (he gave a speech, raised a glass, drank a little wine before heading off to his flat to partake of a doubtless rather classier wind-down bottle of something after a hard day’s work).
The police failure to act left many baffled, including the barrister Adam Wagner, who knows a thing or two about Covid regulations. But there have been sufficient clues to understand their thinking and, potentially, to suggest that the Labour leader Keir Starmer has an even better case to be let off the hook for his own apparent “beergate” infraction in Durham.